Women’s History Month series

History Council of Victoria banner

Links to interviews (and transcripts) with Melbourne women who protested against the Vietnam War and the National Service Act.

Introduction

Jean McLean

Diana Crunden

Jill Reichstein

(list continues below)

Continue reading →

Wind of Earth, Wind of Tau Ceti

I read this thanks to the publisher, Aqueduct Press. It’s out in December, and can be preordered from their website.

This is a “fix-up” novel, comprised in part of stories published elsewhere. I hadn’t read any of those, so this was entirely new to me – I therefore don’t know whether McDermott has made any changes to the originals. Additionally, I would describe it as more like a mosaic novel than a traditional narrative. It doesn’t follow linear time, it doesn’t follow all the same characters – but, as a mosaic, it builds up a picture of a time, a society, and a person.

The novel opens with the titular Wind as a grandmother on Tau Ceti. Her daughter-in-law has died; Wind is trying to help her son and granddaughter. Humans are still living under domes as they terraform the planet, and while the planet isn’t quite as inimical as it could be, it’s still not easy. There is a shift, then, too Wind as an adolescent on Earth: her parents are divorcing, the custody battle is bitter – and neither parent is great. Wind’s relationship with her father and grandmother are central, as is the slowly decaying social and physical infrastructure around her.

The rest of the novel follows Wind initially to the moon, to live with her mother, and then eventually to Tau Ceti. Different chapters follow a school friend of Wind’s, techs who work on the stasis chambers, Wind’s eventual husband and child. It means we get a broader understanding of the problems confronting different parts of society, and how different folks are coping with it, than would be possible just through following Wind – who isn’t privileged, far from it, but still has a particular experience.

Something I can’t figure out is whether some of the discrepancies across the novel are deliberate – perhaps to reflect how memory works; or whether they’re an artefact of coming from various original stories. They’re not massive discrepancies – what Wind was like as a child, mostly; I choose to read them as deliberate, and see them as adding to the mosaic-ness.

One thing I will note: sometimes it’s remarkable what small thing stands out as an indicator of how an author’s background is different from a reader’s. There’s a moment when one of the characters is bemoaning their lack of a water ration and begs access to Wind’s so he can have a shower. Wind agrees but says he can only have a really short one. Just three minutes. As someone who lived through a prolonged drought, for whom a three-minute standard is entirely standard (and entirely sufficient)… well. Lol, I guess.

I really, really enjoyed this. It’s science fiction interested in social development and social issues. Wind is entirely believable, and her Earth society is – sadly – too. McDermott’s style is engaging and immersive. I’m glad this exists.

The Ongoing Odyssey of Jack de Crow

Read c/ NetGalley and the publisher. It’s out in January.

I read the first Jack de Crow some years ago, and was fascinated by Sandy’s adventures – and also a little, well, nonplussed at his remarkable laissez faire attitude. Which is partly a reflection on me and my preference for things to be somewhat organised, and partly amazement that his extraordinary “she’ll be right” attitude did not turn into serious catastrophe.

Twenty years later, Mackinnon goes out again – in a different Crow, which is a whole (remarkable, boggling) story in its own right – this time going from east to west – Romania to Venice.

How you’ll feel about this book will depend on two key things, for my money:

  • How do you feel about someone who sets out on an epic voyage with really very little by way of preparation?
  • How do you feel about someone who only manages to avoid catastrophe through the fact that helpful strangers turn up an astonishing number of times?

… it really is remarkable that Mackinnon doesn’t suffer any worse on this trip than he did. He capsizes, loses bits of kit, loses his wallet, sleeps rough; deals with an epic amount of administration and contradictory instructions (his boat is so small it doesn’t fit within a lot of regulatory frameworks).

Still: those are the parts that had me shaking my head in disbelief. Other parts had me shaking my head in awe, particularly the fabulous places he sees from the water, and yes those instances when someone with whom he doesn’t share a language turns up to save the day. Mackinnon has an easy-to-read style – although again, sometimes his breeziness in the face of near-disaster is a bit much – and a delightful turn of phrase. He’s well read in history and mythology and literature, and makes various connections along the way, which isn’t hard when you’re sailing in the Aegean and you have some Classics background.

If you enjoy travel books, this will probably appeal. If you’re less easily freaked out by things going wrong during someone else’s travels than I, you will probably enjoy this even more than I did – and, despite what it sounds like, I did enjoy it! I have had small adventures myself but for ones like this I am delighted to be an armchair traveller and enjoy someone else’s descriptions.

Stargate SG1: season 5

Season 1; Season 2; Season 3; Season 4

Previously, on… the team got stuck four millions of light years away, with Apophis on their tail. It’s very much a frying pan / fire situation, as although Apophis seems to be dead – or at least everyone on his ship is – the ship is infested with Replicators. Whee!

Plus, Sam has kept her very cute pixie cut.

Meanwhile Teal’c has been brainwashed back to being in love with Apophis; there’s an entire episode of going through his backstory so that he can re-live how he got to being anti-Apophis. So that was traumatic, especially for Dr Frasier, who feels he’s being tortured by having pain meds withheld.

IMPORTANTLY! This is season 5! Which means episode 100! Which means “Wormhole X-treme”!!! I cannot tell you how often “It’s what I do” (etc) gets used in my house. I love everything this episode says about how the show thinks about itself. Why doesn’t someone who’s out of phase fall through the floor? And I’m pretty sure most of the cast of the show are folks who work on Stargate.

I really like that Stargate follows up on some of its earlier narratives, and there’s quite a few in this season. We go back to Cassandra, and the fact that there are still effects from Nirrti’s actions years before. And then we flip back to the planet of the Unas, because an arse has kidnapped some and enslaved them, and Daniel insists they need to do something about it. They’re not even being subtle about the metaphors in this one. In the very next episode we get some fallout from the Russians using the stargate. This episode is basically a variation on The Mummy?? Goa’uld was in a sarcophagus but because his priests rebelled, something was put inside to eat him while being kept alive by said sarcophagus… and the something is also riffing on Alien, coming out of a cocoon and scuttling around. When you factor in that it’s got a symbiote inside, which means it’s looking to find a new host, it’s an even closer parallel. More follow up stories follow: back to the Tollan. Narim has Sam’s voice as his house’s voice and that’s just creepy. And to connect another set of dots, the Tollan are secretly being bullied by the Goa’uld Tanith! We meet those arses the Aschen again. I have to see Kinsey’s face again though, so that’s less than awesome. A bit later in the season we get an episode harking back to that NID black ops team: this time, SG1 has to undo some mistakes made by those other arses. It’s further proof that those “my country right or wrong” types really are awful.

Continue reading →

Helm, by Sarah Hall

I have no idea who recommended this book to me. But it was strongly enough suggested that I immediately got it from the library, and here we are.

This book is brilliant.

I’ve classified it under fantasy, as it kind of is – I mean, some of the narrative is from the wind’s perspective, and it imagines life from the perspective of people ranging from a Neolithic woman to a modern meteorologist. But it’s really one of those books where clear genre boundaries break down. It’s not exactly realist literature, as that description points out, but… *shrug*. Maybe it’s an example of how genre descriptions can sometimes be useless. (I note that Goodreads calls it magical realism.)

So: the Helm is the only named wind in England. It exists for very particular meteorological reasons in a very specific part of Cumbria. And sometimes it can be immensely destructive. This is the wind that Hall gives a voice to, and – not exactly volition, but certainly awareness. That’s one part of the book.

As well as Helm’s experience of the world, Hall presents other stories across several centuries. There’s NaNay, a Neolithic villager who has a vision as a child that drives her entire life. There’s Michael Lang, in the thirteenth century – a spectacularly zealous Christian man convinced Helm is of the devil. The eighteenth century Catherine de Peyster, married to a strongly Christian man for whom Catherine’s playful pagan ways are anathema. Thomas Bodger, gentleman scientist of the nineteenth century, come to try and understand Helm and leaving his ailing wife at home. Little Janni, mid-twentieth century, who plays with Helm and whose imaginings are too much for her mother. Jude Ferguson, retired copper and avid hang glider. And Selima, the meteorologist – living some indeterminate time in the future, but not too far – investigating plastic particulates in the atmosphere and dealing with anti-science types.

It’s a glorious spread of stories. They’re all people who want to understand, but who go about it in very different ways. Mostly not wrong (although Michael Lang, I’m unconvinced by), but ways that would generally be seen as incompatible. With the exception of NaNay, we’re plonked into the middle of a story: we get glimpses of where Selima or Jude have been, to bring them to their point of contact with Helm, but no great detail. And we’re left in the middle, too; Hall has no problem with ambiguity or a lack of resolution. NaNay, though: we get pretty much her entire story, which is such a fascinating choice I’m going to be chewing on it for a while.

And to complement all of this, there are wonderful informative section that reminded me of some of Kim Stanley Robinson’s choices, in books like 2312: a list of Helm’s alternative names, or descriptions of objects found around Helm’s area, or other named winds around the world.

In all, this is an absorbing, glorious, brilliant book.

Stargate SG1, s4

Season 1; Season 2; Season 3

Season 3

We left season 3 with Jack, Sam and Teal’c having just destroyed Thor’s ship to try and destroy the Replicators, but did our heroes get off via stargate?? We know at least one of the replicators survived… and we start the fourth season in a Russian submarine hearing weird things. More importantly Daniel has had a time to get a sleek haircut, around dealing with the consequences of not staying in bed after his appendicitis. And Teal’c has a WEIRD BLONDE SUPER-SOUL PATCH BEARD THING? (Which fortunately only lasts less than half the season.) And I think Sam has had a haircut too – well, it’s longer, and more curly. (And she gets a cute little pixie a bit later in the season, too, which really works for her.)

ANYWAY. We also learn that the most advanced Asgard ship is The O’Neill. THAT is hilarious – and the only thing funnier is that Sam tells them to use it as a bait and blow it up.

The episode with the Eurodans (which WordPress just autocorrected to European, which is… appropriate) is one of my least favourite episodes: the grotesque nature of Alar and his people is so insidious, and Jack is so easily swayed – until his buddy Teal’c is a problem – that I find it really hard to watch. BUT the immediate next episode is where the team gets magic strength armbands and that, too, is hilarious. As is Jack and Daniel’s competition for Anise’s attention. Anise/Freya’s outfits get outrageous across this season. I mean… And, of course, this brings us to the episode that sparked one million fan fics, because both Jack and Sam have to admit their feelings for one another. OOOOH. And it’s followed by the other episode that spawned a million fics, with Jack and Teal’c going all groundhog day. This is probably the episode I rewatched the most, back in the day. It’s just so funny (mostly). (There are, I think, a number of Daniel/Jack moments in this season that must also have launched a million fanfics, but I’m not as good at seeing those.)

Last season I commented there were no significant cameos, but then we get Deanna Troi! Marina Sirtis! With a Russian accent! Because of course the Russians found the stargate and got it open. This episode aired in 2000, which makes the maybe-friendly maybe-enemy storyline with Russia really quite fascinating. Meanwhile, there’s some other BSG alum – Alessandro Juliani, a Cylon (Matthew Bennett), and the fabulous Lorena Gale is briefly an archivist. And Steven Williams, whom I recognise from many shows, got to play a general. And holy shit General Michael E. Ryan who was an actual Chief of Staff of the US Air Force plays the Chief of Staff of the US Air Force. What. Even.

Continue reading →

Ode to the Half-Broken

Several people have been raving about this for a few months, and I finally got around to reading it. (As with the Isabel J Kim, I am not late to reading this – it only came out in May! They were early.) If you are even vaguely interested in sentient robots, post-collapse of the existing world, getting-a-ragtag-team-together stories, with a healthy dollop of snark, you just want to stop reading this now and go read the book.

The (deliberately, consciously) unnamed narrator wakes up having lost 36 hours, in a bathtub, with their leg missing. They’re a robot so that’s not life-threatening – the electromagnets in the tub are a bigger problem – but they’re still human-shaped, so it’s going to present a locomotive issue. Once they finally get out of the tub – there’s a talking dog involved, it’s not as twee as it sounds, not least because the dog would be angry at having the word applied to them – our narrator’s mission is straightforward: find whichever bastard stole their leg and retrieve it. Which of course necessitates figuring out some stopgap (heh) for the missing leg, which means talking to a lot more folks than they’ve talked to in about two decades, and leaving their home which ditto.

This is the getting-the-team-together aspect, because of course some of the folks they meet over time end up joining in, for reasons of their own. Our narrator’s quest ends up being much more than they bargained for (of course). Their world has a lot of robots, of varying sizes, abilities, intelligence levels, and attitudes towards both other robots and humans. There are humans, but it’s a lot fewer than there are now.

That’s only half the narrative, though. The other half is set some indeterminate time in the past – that is, it starts in 2037, but we don’t know when the leg-stealing occurs. In this past, Dr Milton has figured out how to create mindchips, which will enable sentience to form – as has happened with our robot narrator. Milton is interested in the science but not the business, which is bad because it means other people who have taken over the business in ways that he did not expect or desire. This part of the narrative covers several years, and gives a glimpse into how things got to where they are in the “now” of the rest of the book.

There are some obvious parallels to be drawn between this robot and Murderbot, which I’m sure other folks have drawn. Both wish to have nothing to do with gender; both have issues with names. Both would prefer to just be left alone – this narrator has been working on entomology for decades rather than watching soap operas, but really, that’s basically Desperate Ant-wives. Both end up interacting with humans in ways they would rather not; most of the time I think Palmer’s character is less anti-social than Murderbot, but I’m ambivalent about that. This is not to say that they’re the same, of course! But both Palmer and Wells are riffing on a long genealogy of robots/AIs and the variety of ways they might interact with humans, and other robots, if you don’t choose the Skynet option.

Again, the short version is that I enjoyed this enormously. I liked the writing itself, I was intrigued by the characters, some of the villains were excellent villains and others were suitably ambivalent and complex. Our main narrator totally won my heart, and the revelations about their history were beautifully presented, drip-fed at a rate that didn’t make me bored or anxious. 100% will read again.

Sublimation, Isabel J Kim

I feel like I’m late to this party, because so many people I know have been talking about it, but it’s actually only a 2026 book! So I am not late, they’re just early.

This book is brilliant and if you’re up for a world that’s just off from ours – in a very significant way and yet still the world is recognisably ours – you would do worse than just go out on a limb and read this. But if you need to know more…

This is a world where crossing a border might give rise to an “instance” of yourself. Not sure if you do want to go home from that holiday? Not sure if you want to take that overseas posting? Being forced out of your home by natural or human forces? Any of these might create an instance. Who is a real, live, human being, with all of your memories and traits up to that moment. They are you. But they stay, while you go – or they go, and you stay.

I’m sure you can imagine some of the large-scale problems, as well as the small-scale. For migration, as well as for families.

Soyoung instanced when she was a young girl; she lives in Korea, while her instance, who goes by Rose, lives in America – with the instance of Soyoung’s mother. Yujin instances when he leaves Korea for study leave in the US; they also live in those two countries.

Here’s the thing I didn’t mention: if instances meet, and touch, they will generally reintegrate. Again, you can probably imagine the large- and small-scale problems. What if one instance wants to reintegrate, and the other doesn’t? Reintegrating gives the person both sets of memories – imagine living like that!

And now, imagine the techbros rubbing their hands at the opportunities this affords: what about something to guarantee forced reintegration can’t happen? What about… well, there are all sorts of possibilities if instancing could somehow be managed.

Sublimation isn’t about the technological stuff, exactly, but it does run through the whole book: Yujin’s instance, YJ, works for the company who made MERGEBREAK (bracelets that should stop reintegration). And the whole question of reintegrating or not is at the core of the novel, so external efforts to affect that are pretty important.

This is a book about migration, of course: about choosing to migrate, about the consequences of doing so, and what it means to leave somewhere. And it’s about identity – how could it not be: what does it mean if you’re torn between choices? How can you reconcile with yourself?

I haven’t even mentioned the structure of the novel. First thing: large swathes of it are written in the second person. Bold choice! It means you (heh) switching between a Soyoung, Rose, Yujin and YJ – you say, you do, you think – and it makes the whole experience remarkably visceral. And when you (heh) suddenly flip to reading in the third person, it’s quite discombobulating. Which is really clever. Second thing: there’s a lot of asides about literature across the novel. There are references to a Korean fairytale, a Korean song, The Odyssey, and the Book of Genesis. The last two are what I know best, but they all suggest the same thing: in a world where instancing has always happened, how does that change literature? What if Odysseus instanced when he left Ithaca – what does that say about him? And what if – this one is the most challenging, IMO – the act of creating the world (and everything in it) was one absolutely epic example of instancing?

Some thoughts about the very end below the cut, but look – this book is just great, you should read it.

Continue reading →

Frankenstein Rex

First off: if you’re reading this while the blurb still talks about immortality and seeking an heir, that blurb is WRONG. I won’t speculate about how that happened – not my business – but it’s very, very wrong. That is not what this book is about at all.

To head off any other jokes: it’s also not about a dinosaur. It is indeed a play on Shelley’s Frankenstein, and specifically the creature – and yes there’s a whole bit about the name choice.

So what is it about, then? Well, Frankenstein (the creature) has been king of the world for many, many decades. Since not long after Napoleon popped up, in fact, and it’s now just our time. Frankenstein does seem to be immortal; he’s not ageing or changing, and assassination attempts in the past have failed. Of course, that doesn’t stop other people from trying.

Frankenstein rules as a benevolent (ish) dictator. All land belongs to him – with just a couple of carve-outs, like Jerusalem and Mecca – and he leases it back; but he has strict expectations about energy efficiency etc. The lingua franca is French (heh). National sentiment is forbidden, and regarded as irrelevant by the powers that be. Decade on decade, Frankenstein swings between more liberal and more tyrannical. Someone is arrested for planning to assassinate the king… and the novel goes from there.

It’s very important I let you know that the opening chapter has some quite gruesome torture. I had to skim a couple of paragraphs after I realised what was going on. There’s nothing like it for the rest of the book, so it’s a shocking opener but not indicative of the novel as a whole.

As well as being a novel about trying to understand a would-be assassin, this is quite blatantly a book about politics. If there is literally a monster in charge, how do and should humans act? (Yes, of course there is discussion to be had about whether the creature is a monster, and you’ll note that I don’t use ‘monster’ to describe him.) Sometimes there is something darkly appealing about having one person in charge forever and ever! Change is hard and sometimes painful! … and there will always be collaborators, who are either all-in on the regime or out for whatever they can get; and there will be people who are just muddling along and putting up with it because what else are you going to do; and there will be some few who are defiant and maybe reckless and endanger both themselves and others because they think there’s a better way. Where does righteousness lie? What is appropriate? I know what I think; and Roberts manages to be a lot more nuanced than many other writers would achieve (which does not surprise me, because… well. It’s Adam Roberts. Man knows how to be complicated).

I do have thoughts about the ending; spoilers below the cut.

Continue reading →

Rakesfall

I just.

What.

Why have I read so many not-straightforward books recently?

Why do I read books where I’m really not sure that I’m smart enough to understand them?

Well, in this case it’s because so many people talked about this book that I got incredible FOMO and decided to finally take the plunge, even though I knew – from all that talking – that it was going to make my head spin.

And it did. Mostly in a “I think this is enjoyable?” kind of way, but… yeh. Spinning.

I could try to outline the story, but that would be something of a fool’s errand. There’s versions of worlds, or perhaps dimensions? Some characters maybe keep recurring across centuries. There are things hidden from mortal ken, and probably none of the worlds are our world, and things happened in the past that echo through to the future. You should definitely read Ian Mond’s review of it in Locus, because he does a better job of summing it up than I could.

So why bother writing this review? Really I just wanted to note, out loud as it were, how impressed I was while also flailing a bit to understand what was going on. Even through that flailing, I was drawn on, because the writing is just that good. And I felt hope that, even if I didn’t completely understand everything by the end, I’d at least have some sense of… completion, or resolution, or something. And I did. Not entirely completion, but certainly as though events and characters made some sort of sense, even if there were still gaps.

It really is excellent. Hard, and excellent. I can’t quite imagine where Chandrasekera will go next – anywhere, I guess.

What A Fish Looks Like

I’ve liked everything I’ve seen out of Stelliform Press; they focus on fiction that centres climate change and how it affects the planet and people. Often hopeful, like solarpunk, but not in a blinkered, rosy-glasses way.

The overarching story here is that a spaceship is soon to take off, and some tickets have come available for folks who didn’t expect it. The question of whether to take one or not is driving wedges between people. In particular, between Seb and Jay. So the story is sort of about that. But it’s about more than that: it’s about community, and how a changed world can be understood, and how and why we tell stories – to understand what’s going on and to shape what’s going on.

Rather than being a straightforward narrative, Beker presents a montage of myths and fairy stories, along with ephemera like party invitations and graffiti. The stories are found in a book Seb has left for Jay. They remake old stories to be more appropriate for the changed world: Beauty and the Beast becomes What a Fish Looks Like; The Little Mermaid becomes Playlist 4Merx in Times of Sea Levels Rising.

Characters come in and out – mentioned in ephemera and then in a story, times looping in and out, so it’s sometimes a tease trying to figure out who is known to be where. It’s incredibly clever and I can only assume Beker must have created one of those enormous pin boards with string to keep it all together (literally or metaphorically).

I’m late to this party but I can see why folks were talking about it last year. The structure works really well – done with thoughtfulness, the inclusion of ephemera adds enormous depth to a world, and the design works beautifully here. I like Beker’s ambivalence about the state of the world: maybe leaving will be the right decision! Maybe staying and trying to make things better on this planet is the right decision! … maybe both are right, for different people. And I liked, too, the hints at community building and support. I’m increasingly being drawn to that sort of fiction.